The Individualism Trap: How Modern Life Is Making Us Miserable (And What Groups Can Do About It)

The Full Listener's Guide

Photo by Papaioannou Kostas on Unsplash

🎧 In This Episode

We sit down with Colin Fisher, author of "The Collective Edge," to explore how modern individualism is undermining our well-being and performance.

Colin reveals why the groups we're embedded in — from work teams to families — are more powerful than we realize, and shares practical strategies for harnessing collective intelligence.

Listen Now

• Chase Club (Ad Free)

• Spotify

• Apple Podcasts

Sponsored By

• Function Health - Health monitoring platform

• LMNT - Zero-sugar electrolyte drink

• Mizzen+Main - Performance menswear

• Monarch Money - Personal finance tool

• OneSkin - Skin longevity products

Quick Preview

• The 4.5-Person Rule: Why optimal team size matters more than you think

• Sticky Norms: How group behaviors form in the first meeting and become nearly impossible to change

• Us vs. The Problem: The mindset shift that transforms conflict into collaboration

• Psychological Safety: Creating environments where people can take interpersonal risks and thrive

---

❤️‍🔥 A Deeper Dive

Big Ideas

The Individualism Trap: We've been conditioned to believe success comes from individual effort, but this mindset is actually limiting our potential. Colin explains how we're embedded in groups all the time - families, work teams, friend circles - and these invisible forces shape our behavior even when we're alone. The trap is thinking we can solve problems in isolation when, in reality, the real power lies in collective intelligence.

The Power of Group Norms: Every group develops unspoken rules about what's acceptable behavior, and these norms are incredibly "sticky" - they form quickly and persist for months. Whether it's where people sit in meetings or how much they participate, these patterns get established in the very first interaction and become self-reinforcing.

The 60-30-10 Rule: Colin's research shows that 60% of group performance is determined by structure (goals, composition, tasks) before the group even meets. 30% is determined in that crucial first meeting. Only 10% can be influenced afterward. This means getting groups right from the start is absolutely critical.

Psychological Safety as a Foundation: Groups can only reach their full potential when members feel safe taking interpersonal risks - asking questions, admitting mistakes, disagreeing respectfully, and sharing ideas. Without this foundation, even the most talented groups will underperform.

Key Distinctions

Individual vs. Group Solutions

• Traditional approach: Change your psychology, habits, and mindset as an individual

• Group-centered approach: Join groups that facilitate the changes you want to make through supportive norms

Competition vs. Collaboration

• Competitive mindset: "Me vs. you" or "I win, you lose" thinking

• Collaborative mindset: "Us vs. the problem," where success means solving challenges together

Task Conflict vs. Relationship Conflict

• Task conflict: Disagreeing about ideas, methods, or approaches (healthy and productive)

• Relationship conflict: Personal attacks or character judgments (destructive and difficult to recover from)

Instrumental vs. Socio-emotional Goals

• Instrumental goals: Getting specific tasks done (like work projects or household chores)

• Socio-emotional goals: Feeling valued, supported, and connected as group members

Reflection Questions

1. What groups am I currently a part of, and how are they influencing my daily behavior and identity? Think beyond obvious groups - consider your household, neighborhood, online communities, and even the people you commute with.

2. When I'm in group settings, do I tend to speak up early and ask questions, or do I wait to see what others do first? Reflect on how your participation patterns may be shaping norms that either enhance or hinder the group's effectiveness.

3. In my most important relationships (family, work team, friend group), are we operating with an "us vs. the problem" mentality or falling into competitive dynamics? Notice when conversations feel collaborative versus adversarial.

4. What would I want to change about the groups I'm part of, and what role could I play in creating those changes? Even if you're not the leader, you can influence group norms through your own behavior.

5. Am I trying to solve challenges in my life individually when I could benefit from finding or creating groups with shared goals? Consider areas where you're struggling alone that might be easier with collective support.

Practice Opportunities

The First Meeting Protocol: Next time you join a new group or team, consciously set positive norms by asking thoughtful questions, speaking up early, and modeling the behavior you want to see. Remember that what happens in that first interaction will have a lasting impact.

The Relaunch Strategy: If you're leading a group that has developed unhelpful norms, Colin suggests conducting a formal "relaunch" by changing the physical setting, explicitly discussing the behaviors you want moving forward, and creating a sense of starting fresh.

The Question Counter: In your next few meetings, count the number of questions people ask (including yourself). A healthy group will have lots of questions flowing in all directions. If questions are rare, that's a sign the group lacks psychological safety.

Application Framework

Step 1: Assess Your Current Groups

Identify the main groups you're part of and evaluate their health. Look for signs like: Do people ask questions? Can you disagree without it becoming a personal issue? Does everyone participate, or do the same people dominate?

Step 2: Choose Your Influence Strategy

If you're a leader, be intentional about establishing norms from the start. If you're a contributor, model the behavior you want to see—speak up early, ask questions, and foster a sense of psychological safety for others.

Step 3: Apply the "Us vs. The Problem" Framework

When conflict arises, pause and ask: "How can we work together to solve this challenge?" This simple reframe can transform adversarial situations into collaborative problem-solving.

Step 4: Join Purpose-Aligned Groups

Whatever you want to improve in your life, find others who share that goal. The group's norms will naturally support your desired changes in ways that individual willpower alone cannot match.

Step 5: Create New Groups When Needed

If you can't find the right group, create one. As Colin says, leadership is simply finding people who want the same thing you do and bringing them together.

Key Takeaways

• Groups shape us more than we realize: Even when we're alone, we're influenced by what we imagine our various groups would think of our behavior.

• Size matters: The optimal group size is 4 to 5 people. Larger groups struggle with coordination and equal participation.

• First impressions are lasting: Whatever norms get established in a group's first meeting tend to stick for the duration. Be intentional about those early interactions.

• Psychological safety is fragile: It requires consistent effort to create and maintain, yet it's essential for group learning and creativity.

• Individual solutions have limits: Many challenges we try to solve alone would be easier with the right group support and collective intelligence.

• "Us vs. the problem" changes everything: This simple mindset shift transforms competitive dynamics into collaborative problem-solving.

• Connection is a skill: Just like the other four factors of health (move, eat, think, sleep), how we connect with others requires intentional practice and attention.

---

Chasing Excellence is an audience-supported project. To go deeper & to help us do even more, consider:

1. Subscribing to get our free posts or upgrading to receive the Daily Chase posts & bonus content.

2. Grabbing one of our books: Chasing Excellence, Unlocking Potential, or The ABCs of Being Happy & Healthy.

3. Supporting one of our fantastic show sponsors.