Where Do You Feel Most Alive? Why Growing Together Beats Going Alone (w/ Daniel Coyle)
5 Big Ideas, 3 Reflection Questions, 1 Takeaway
We explore Daniel Coyle’s framework for flourishing — the experience of shared, joyful, meaningful growth - and why community might be the most underrated ingredient in building a life that feels fully alive.
You’ll learn why most of us are drowning in task attention while starving for relational attention, how to design awakening cues that pull you out of narrow focus and into presence, and why the most productive thing you can do might be to stop optimizing and start connecting.
Daniel shares insights from his research on flourishing groups - from Olympic athletes in Norwich, Vermont to restaurants like Zingerman’s - and reveals the specific conditions that allow people and communities to thrive together rather than just succeed alone.
Listen Now
Chase Club (Ad Free)
🖐 5 BIG IDEAS
1. Flourishing Is Growth, Shared
Flourishing isn’t about outputs or achievements. It’s not about hitting your goals or checking boxes on a productivity system. Flourishing is the experience of growth that feels joyful and meaningful, and it only happens in community with others.
This definition immediately separates flourishing from success. Machines can be successful. They can be optimized and efficient and productive. But they cannot flourish. Flourishing requires surprise, messiness, connection, and the kind of aliveness that only emerges when people grow together.
The key word here is “shared.” You can improve alone. You can achieve alone. But you cannot flourish alone. Flourishing requires connection - the sense that you’re growing alongside others, that your progress and theirs are intertwined, that you belong to something larger than yourself.
2. We Have Two Attentional Systems
Your brain has two fundamentally different ways of paying attention. Task attention is narrow, focused, instrumental. It’s designed to grab things, control outcomes, and automate processes. Relational attention is wide, open, warm. It’s designed to connect, to wonder, to see relationships and possibilities.
Modern life has trained us to live almost entirely in task attention. We’re constantly grabbing for the next thing, optimizing the next process, controlling the next outcome. And in that mode, we treat everything - including people - as objects to be managed rather than beings to be with.
The cost of this imbalance is enormous. We lose the capacity for presence. We lose the ability to connect deeply. We lose access to the very attention system that makes flourishing possible. The path back isn’t complicated - it’s about creating space to shift from task mode to relational mode. But it does require intention.
3. Awakening Cues Pull You Into Presence
An awakening cue is any behavior or ritual that shifts your attention from narrow to broad, from controlling to connecting. It could be as simple as lighting a candle before you sit down to work. Watching the sunrise once a week. Writing morning pages. Asking someone, “What’s one insight or piece of information you wish you could have captured better?”
These cues aren’t productive in the traditional sense. They don’t accomplish anything. But that’s exactly why they’re powerful. They create a momentary break from the relentless drive to get things done, and in that break, you remember that connection and presence are worthwhile for their own sake.
The key is to design these cues into your life rather than waiting for the mood to strike. Flourishing doesn’t happen by accident. It happens when you intentionally create the conditions for relational attention to click on and stay on long enough to matter.
4. Community Requires a Gradient, Guardrails, and Agency
If you want a group to flourish - whether it’s a family, a team, or a community - you can’t engineer it like a machine. You have to design it like an ecosystem. And ecosystems need three things: a gradient (a direction to flow toward), guardrails (boundaries that keep things contained), and agency (the freedom to move and adapt within that space).
Great leaders of flourishing groups are obsessed with these three elements. They make the horizon crystal clear so everyone knows where they’re headed. They establish guardrails so people know what’s in bounds and what’s out. And then they step back and give people the freedom to explore, create, and surprise within that container.
This is the opposite of micromanagement. It’s also the opposite of chaos. It’s the recognition that human groups are alive and complex, not mechanical and predictable. And when you treat them that way - when you design conditions rather than dictate outcomes - you create space for real flourishing.
5. Annoyance Is the Price of Community
Communities are annoying. They’re messy and imperfect and frustrating. People will let you down. Plans will go sideways. Things won’t go as smoothly as they would if you just did everything yourself.
And that’s exactly why community matters. If it were easy and frictionless, it wouldn’t require you to grow. It wouldn’t ask anything of you. It wouldn’t push you beyond your preferences and comfort zones into the kind of expansiveness that only comes from being with others.
Accepting annoyance as the price of admission is essential. Because if you’re constantly looking for the perfect, frictionless community, you’ll never find it. And you’ll miss out on the transcendent, messy, beautiful experience of actually belonging to something real.
🤔 3 REFLECTION QUESTIONS
1. Where do you feel most alive, and with whom do you feel most deeply yourself?
This is Daniel’s diagnostic question for flourishing. Don’t overthink it - just notice where the sense of aliveness shows up in your life. Is it with certain people? In certain environments? Doing certain kinds of work? Pay attention to those moments, because they’re clues to what flourishing actually feels like for you.
2. How much of your day is spent in task attention versus relational attention?
Take an honest inventory. How much of your time is focused on getting things done, optimizing outcomes, and controlling variables? And how much time is spent in open, warm, connective presence with others or with yourself? If the balance is off, what’s one awakening cue you could build into your daily rhythm?
3. What’s one “yellow door” opportunity in your life right now that you’ve been avoiding?
Yellow doors are the invitations that don’t look super promising at first glance. They’re not obvious red lights or green lights — they’re somewhere in between. But they often lead to the most surprising and meaningful connections. What’s one yellow door you could walk through this week, even if it feels a little uncomfortable?
🔑 1 KEY TAKEAWAY
Flourishing requires you to stop optimizing and start belonging.
We’ve been sold a story that life is a machine to be optimized. That if we just find the right productivity system, the right morning routine, the right set of habits, everything will fall into place. We’ll be efficient and effective and successful, and that will make us happy.
But that’s not how it works. Because machines don’t flourish. Only living things flourish. And living things flourish in community, not in isolation.
The path to flourishing isn’t about doing more or achieving more. It’s about connecting more. It’s about shifting your attention from narrow task mode - where everything is an object to be controlled - to broad relational mode, where everything is alive and worth being with.
This shift requires you to do things that feel unproductive. To light candles and watch sunrises and have long conversations that don’t lead anywhere specific. To say yes to yellow doors even when you’re not sure where they lead. To tolerate the annoyance and messiness of real community instead of retreating into the clean efficiency of solo work.
It requires you to design your life around presence, not just productivity. To ask not just “what’s the most efficient path?” but “where do I feel most alive?” To measure success not by what you accomplished alone, but by what you created and experienced together.
This is a different kind of discipline. The discipline to slow down when everything in you wants to speed up. The discipline to connect when it would be easier to optimize. The discipline to belong, even when belonging is messy and imperfect and asks more of you than you feel like giving.
But that’s where the good stuff is. Not at the peak of the productivity mountain, but in the valleys where people gather and grow together. Where surprise and joy and meaning emerge not from perfect execution, but from shared aliveness.
Ask yourself: Where do you feel most alive? And what would it take to spend more of your life there?
Chasing Excellence is an audience-supported project. To go deeper & to help us do even more, consider:
Subscribing to get our free posts or upgrading to receive the Daily Chase posts & the ChaseTracker app.
Grabbing one of our books: Chasing Excellence, Unlocking Potential, or The ABCs of Being Happy & Healthy.
Supporting one of our fantastic show sponsors.