Coaches Aren't Essential. Here's Why You Need One Anyway.

5 Big Ideas, 3 Reflection Questions, 1 Practice

🎧 In This Episode

We explore what coaches and mentors are actually for — and more importantly, what it takes to get the most out of them.

You’ll learn the three mentorship models Ben uses (paid coach, peer expert trade, and tracking partner), why reciprocity is the non-negotiable at the center of each one, and what you must bring as the mentee: curiosity, vulnerability, and patience.

Listen Now

• Chase Club

• Spotify

• Apple Podcasts

---

🖐 5 BIG IDEAS

1. Coaches Aren’t Essential — But They’re Invaluable Shortcuts

Essential means without them you can’t do it — and that’s simply not true. But “not essential” is not the same as “not worth it.”

Coaches and mentors get you to places you couldn’t reach on your own, and they get you there faster.

We shouldn’t feel dependent on coaches or mentors, but we should actively seek them. The cost of going without one isn’t inability — it’s slower, harder progress.

2. Every Mentorship Needs a Value Exchange

The clearest lesson from Ben’s three mentorship relationships is that reciprocity isn’t optional — it’s the foundation.

His paid business coach gets money. Marcus gets Ben as his health and fitness mentor in return. Derek trades operational expertise for culture-building insights.

Even Warren Buffett’s offer to work for Benjamin Graham for free wasn’t enough — Graham famously replied, “You’re overpriced.” The mentor has to pour enormous energy into the relationship. If you can’t identify what you’re bringing to a mentor, you shouldn’t be surprised when they say no.

Reciprocity is the price of admission.

3. The Friend-Mentor Blend Works When Both Parties Contribute

Ben’s relationship with Marcus started as friendship — working out together, then hanging out, then meeting weekly for half a day every Wednesday.

It morphed into something more structured: personal catch-up first, then business conversation. The reason it worked was that Marcus got something real in return — Ben’s health and fitness expertise, and a beta-testing environment for the business scaling model Marcus was developing.

Friendship alone doesn’t create mentorship. But a friendship where both people bring expertise the other lacks can become one of the most powerful development relationships available.

4. Curiosity, Vulnerability, & Patience Are Prerequisites

Ben names three things every mentee must bring.

First, curiosity: approaching the relationship with a growth mindset, genuinely wanting to improve rather than to prove how much you already know.

Second, vulnerability: taking off your armor and saying “here’s what I’m actually struggling with” — because the more open you are, the more useful the relationship becomes.

Third, patience: the mentor’s guidance often doesn’t go directly from your question to a clean answer. It goes somewhere unexpected, and only after sitting with it — exploring the implications, connecting the dots — do you arrive somewhere better than you expected.

5. The Best Mentors Help You See What You Don’t

The core value of any coach, mentor, or good book is helping you see what you can’t see because you’re too deep inside your own experience.

We all have blind spots shaped by our history, our perspective, and our past failures. Great mentors don’t just give answers — they expand what you’re able to see.

Ben’s business coach has run thousands of quarterly meetings. He doesn’t zoom out with Ben — he’s already on the outside, looking in.

Gretzky didn’t skate to where the puck was. He went to where it was going. That’s what a great mentor does.

---

---

🤔 3 REFLECTION QUESTIONS

1. Where are you defaulting to the giver role to avoid the discomfort of asking for help?

Patrick admits this about himself — he’s more comfortable listening and advising than being the one saying “I don’t have this figured out.” Think about your closest relationships. Are there places where you stay in the advice-giving role because vulnerability feels harder than competence? What would shift if you asked for help instead?

2. Which of Ben’s three mentorship models do you currently have — and which are you missing?

Ben’s three models: a paid professional coach (transactional exchange), a peer expert trade (Marcus — health for business expertise), and a tracking partner (Derek — shared goals, quarterly deep dives). Most people have zero of these. Which is closest to what you have? Which one, if added, would return the most to your life right now?

3. What would it look like to bring more curiosity, vulnerability, or patience to a relationship that could be giving you more?

Think of one person in your life — a mentor, a friend, a coach — where you know you’re not getting everything the relationship could offer. Which of the three ingredients are you shortchanging? What would it look like to show up differently in the next conversation?

---

🎯 1 PRACTICE

Map your mentorship relationships this week.

Pull out a piece of paper and draw three columns: Paid Coach, Peer Expert Trade, Tracking Partner. In each column, write the name of the person (if any) who fills that role in your life right now.

If a column is empty, that’s useful data — not a reason to panic, but a clear gap worth acknowledging. Then ask: which gap, if filled, would most accelerate where you’re trying to go?

You don’t need all three. But you do need to know what you have and what you’re missing. Most people skip this inventory entirely and wonder why they keep hitting the same ceiling.

---