What Modern Culture Gets Wrong About Fulfillment: Money, Comfort, & the Cost of Believing the Lies
5 Big Ideas, 3 Reflection Questions, 1 Takeaway
This week’s episode is a bit different. Instead of a single conversation, we’re bringing you three conversations that together tell one story: what modern culture gets wrong about fulfillment, and what actually works instead.
These three episodes are foundational to an essay we’re publishing in a few days called The Two Lies Everyone Believes (and the Truth That Sets You Free).
In synthesizing ideas from eleven episodes and four books, we kept returning to these three conversations because they map the entire journey from diagnosis to cost to cure.
Together, they show us the four idols our culture worships, the comfort crisis that’s making us weaker, and the five regrets that reveal what happens when we believe the lies for a lifetime.
You’ll walk away with a clear understanding of why chasing money, power, pleasure, and fame keeps you stuck, why modern comfort is an evolutionary mismatch that creates anxiety and depression, and why the only path to a life without regret runs directly through intentional discomfort.
🎧 Listen Now
Chase Club (Ad Free)
🖐 5 BIG IDEAS
1. The Four Idols Are Thin Desires That Crack Under Pressure
Modern culture prescribes a clear formula for fulfillment: chase money, power, pleasure, and fame. These are what philosopher Thomas Aquinas called the four idols, and what writer Luke Burgis calls thin desires in his book Wanting. They’re borrowed from the world around us rather than generated from within.
The problem isn’t that these things are inherently bad. The problem is that they promise fulfillment but can’t deliver it. They’re extrinsic goals that depend on external validation and circumstances beyond our control. When we organize our entire lives around acquiring them, we end up trapped in a cycle of striving that never satisfies.
The research backs this up: people who prioritize extrinsic goals report lower life satisfaction, more anxiety and depression, and less meaning than those who focus on intrinsic pursuits like personal growth, relationships, and contribution. The idols crack under pressure because they were never designed to bear the weight of a human life.
2. Modern Comfort Is an Evolutionary Mismatch Creating a Crisis
For 99.9% of human history, survival required regular exposure to physical challenge, environmental variability, and genuine risk. Our bodies and minds evolved in that context. But in just a few generations, we’ve engineered out almost all discomfort from daily life.
Michael Easter calls this the Comfort Crisis. We’re living in temperature-controlled environments, sitting for most of the day, eating highly processed foods, and avoiding anything that feels physically or emotionally difficult. The result isn’t the paradise we expected. It’s an epidemic of anxiety, depression, and a pervasive sense that something is missing.
The evolutionary mismatch shows up everywhere. Our bodies expect to move, lift, carry, and navigate variable terrain. Our minds expect to face challenges, solve problems, and test ourselves against meaningful obstacles. When we remove all that discomfort, we don’t become happier. We become untested, soft, and fundamentally unprepared for the inevitable difficulties life brings.
3. Being Untested Creates Anxiety Because Uncertainty Feels Dangerous
Here’s the paradox: the more we avoid discomfort, the more anxious we become about it. When we’re never tested, we have no evidence of our own capability. Uncertainty stops being an opportunity and starts feeling like a threat.
This explains why so many people feel paralyzed when facing even small challenges. If your entire life is optimized for comfort, then any deviation from that baseline feels catastrophic. You haven’t built the capacity to handle discomfort, so your nervous system treats every bump in the road like a five-alarm fire.
The antidote is simple but not easy: deliberate exposure to challenge. When you regularly do hard things, your relationship with discomfort changes. You build evidence that you can handle more than you think. Anxiety decreases not because life gets easier, but because you become more capable of navigating whatever comes.
4. The Five Regrets Reveal the Cost of Chasing the Idols
Bronnie Ware spent years in palliative care, sitting with people in their final weeks of life. She documented what they told her, and five regrets showed up again and again. When you read them, you realize: every single one is the direct result of chasing the four idols while avoiding discomfort.
Working too hard for status and money. Living for others’ expectations instead of pursuing what you actually wanted. Not expressing feelings because conflict felt uncomfortable. Losing friendships because real connection requires vulnerability. Not allowing yourself to be happy because you were waiting for some external condition to change first.
These aren’t random regrets. They’re the predictable outcome of organizing your life around the four idols while avoiding the discomfort required for genuine fulfillment. The five regrets are a mirror showing us exactly where the cultural prescription leads if we follow it all the way to the end.
5. The Way Out Is Through, Not Around
If the idols point us in the wrong direction, and comfort makes us weaker, and avoidance leads to regret, then what’s the path forward? It runs directly through the discomfort we’ve been trying to avoid.
The way through isn’t about seeking suffering for its own sake. It’s about deliberately choosing challenges that build capacity for what matters. It’s about protocol work, everyday challenges that feel hard but are entirely manageable. It’s about treating the gym as a laboratory where you practice returning to center when things get difficult.
This is where the rubber meets the road. You can understand the four idols intellectually. You can recognize the comfort crisis and nod along to the five regrets. But none of that matters until you start doing the daily work of walking through the discomfort instead of engineering your life to avoid it.
🤔 3 REFLECTION QUESTIONS
1. Which of the four idols has the strongest grip on you right now?
Money, power, pleasure, or fame. Be honest with yourself about which one you’re organizing your life around. What decisions have you made recently that reveal what you’re actually chasing? And how is that pursuit affecting your health, your relationships, and your sense of meaning?
2. Where have you optimized your life for comfort at the expense of capacity?
Think about the daily discomforts you’ve systematically removed. Maybe it’s a physical challenge, maybe it’s difficult conversations, maybe it’s the vulnerability of trying something you might fail at. What has avoiding that discomfort cost you? What evidence do you have of your own capability when things get hard?
3. If you were facing your last days, what would you regret not doing?
Don’t answer quickly. Actually sit with this question. What are you not pursuing because it feels too hard, too uncertain, or too far outside others’ expectations? What relationships are you neglecting? What version of yourself are you not allowing to exist? And what’s one small step you could take this week toward minimizing that future regret?
🔑 1 KEY TAKEAWAY
The cultural prescription for fulfillment is backwards, and the only path to a life without regret runs through the discomfort we’re trying to avoid.
The synthesis we’ve been doing across these episodes reveals something that should be obvious but isn’t: everything our culture tells us to chase leads away from fulfillment, and everything our culture tells us to avoid is actually the path toward it.
Chasing the four idols creates dissatisfaction. Optimizing for comfort creates weakness. Avoiding discomfort creates regret. The entire cultural framework is inverted.
The way forward requires seeing these lies clearly, understanding what they cost, and then doing the daily work of building a different life. That’s the journey we map out in the full essay, The Two Lies Everyone Believes (and the Truth That Sets You Free). It pulls together everything from these three conversations plus insights from eight more episodes, and it gives you a practical framework for walking through the discomfort instead of around it.
Note: the essay will be published on Thursday, Feb 19th. Make sure you’re subscribed so we can send it directly to you!
Chasing Excellence is an audience-supported project. To go deeper & to help us do even more, consider:
Subscribing to get our free posts or upgrading to receive the Daily Chase posts & the ChaseTracker app.
Grabbing one of our books: Chasing Excellence, Unlocking Potential, or The ABCs of Being Happy & Healthy.
Supporting one of our fantastic show sponsors.