Anti-Fragile Confidence: Your Protocol Beats Your Motivation (w/ Brian Johnson)
5 Big Ideas, 3 Reflection Questions, 1 Takeaway
We explore the concept of anti-fragile confidence with Brian Johnson, founder of Heroic and author of Arete: Activate Your Heroic Potential — the idea that you don’t just bounce back from challenges, you get stronger because of them.
You’ll learn why your protocol matters more than your motivation, how ancient wisdom and modern science converge on the same principles for living well, and what it means to close the gap between the person you’re capable of being and the person you’re actually being in any given moment.
Brian shares his Seven Objectives framework for activating heroic potential, the Trevor Moawad exercise that reveals what you do when you’re at your best, and the life-changing prescription from Phil Stutz: “The worse you feel, the more committed you are to your protocol.”
Listen Now
Chase Club (Ad Free)
🖐 5 BIG IDEAS
1. Anti-Fragile Confidence: The Wind That Fuels Your Fire
Most people think the opposite of fragile is resilient — something that bounces back after stress. But Nassim Taleb introduced a better concept: anti-fragility, which means getting stronger from stress.
A wine glass is fragile. It breaks when you drop it. A plastic cup is resilient. It bounces back. But your muscles, your bones, your immune system — these are anti-fragile. They need stress to grow stronger. The question is: can your confidence work the same way?
Phil Stutz taught Brian a concept called “emotional stamina” — your ability to handle life’s inevitable pain, uncertainty, and hard work. Most people spiral out when challenges hit. They abandon their routines, stop doing what they know works, and make things worse. Anti-fragile confidence means you use challenges as triggers to double down on your fundamentals.
As Seneca said: “Disaster is virtue’s opportunity.” The worse things get, the more committed you become to your protocol.
2. Your Protocol Beats Your Motivation (Every Single Time)
Trevor Moawad taught Brian an exercise that changed everything: Write down the 10 things you were doing when you were at your absolute best. Then ask yourself: How many of those am I doing now?
The version of you doing those things will outperform the version not doing them every single time. Not sometimes. Not most of the time. Every time.
This is what Brian calls “taking your prior best and making it your new baseline.” Most people treat their peak performance as a special moment — something that happened when everything aligned perfectly. But the truth is simpler: you were doing specific things consistently. When you stop doing those things, your performance drops. When you return to them, your performance rises.
Your protocol is the collection of fundamentals you do regardless of how you feel. Motivation is unreliable. It comes and goes. Your protocol is what remains when motivation disappears — and it’s the only thing you can truly count on.
3. The Ultimate Game Is Flourishing Through Virtue, Not Fame
For 2,500 years, philosophers and psychologists have been asking the same question: What’s the purpose of life? Aristotle gave a one-word answer: flourish. In Greek, it’s eudaimonia — a good soul, a life well-lived.
Modern positive psychology, led by Martin Seligman, asked the same question and came to the same conclusion. The data is clear: if you pursue extrinsic motivators like fame, wealth, and status, even if you’re successful, you’ll be “less psychologically stable” than those pursuing intrinsic motivators like becoming a better person, deepening relationships, and contributing to your community.
In any given moment, you’re capable of being this version of you. If you’re being that version, there’s a gap. In that gap exists regret, anxiety, and disillusionment. When you close the gap and express your best self — what the Greeks called arete (virtue or excellence) — you experience flourishing.
This isn’t about perfection. It’s about consistently closing the gap more often. That’s the ultimate game.
4. Dominate the Fundamentals: Physiology Drives Psychology
Brian’s biggest insight from 25 years of studying optimal performance: fix your fundamentals before trying to solve complex psychological challenges.
The greatest failing of modern approaches to mental health is ignoring the underlying physiology. When you dominate the basics — eating, moving, sleeping, breathing, focusing — for 15 to 60 days, the frequency and intensity of your psychological challenges decreases. Your highs get higher. Your lows get higher. The scaffolding stabilizes.
Brian’s daily non-negotiables: in bed 8-9 hours, meditate 11-60 minutes every morning, move his body (sun salutations, pull-ups, burpees, rowing, 10k steps), and prioritize relationships (phone-free time with kids, love note to his wife, daily hugs).
This isn’t sexy. It’s not Instagram-worthy. But John Wooden, the greatest coach in sports history, wouldn’t let the best athletes of his generation touch a basketball until he personally taught them how to put on their socks and shoes correctly. Why? Because a blister from improper sock placement means you can’t perform at your highest level. The basics matter more than the sexy stuff.
5. Consistency Is the Exponential (Not the Add-On)
Brian’s Soul Force equation: Soul Force = (Energy × Focus × What’s Important Now) ^ Consistency.
If your energy is 100, your focus is 100, and your clarity on what’s important now is 100, you get 100 × 100 × 100 = 1,000,000. But that’s not the end of the equation. You raise that to the power of consistency. 1,000,000 ^ 100 = infinity.
You can’t do this once at a weekend event. You can’t go to a seminar, get fired up, and expect it to last. You must come back day after day after day. Consistency isn’t something you add to the equation — it’s the exponential that transforms everything else.
The most creative act you can perform is the speed with which you recover from falling short. Marcus Aurelius called it the “equanimity game”: when force of circumstance knocks you off your center, see how fast you can get it back. A master of Aikido once told his student: “I lose my center all the time. I just recover so quickly you don’t notice.”
Make it a game. How quickly can you return to your protocol?
🤔 3 REFLECTION QUESTIONS
1. What were you doing when you were at your absolute best — and how many of those things are you doing right now?
Write down 10 specific behaviors, habits, or practices that were present during your peak performance. Be honest about the gap between that version of you and the current version. What’s one thing you can bring back today?
2. Where do you spiral out instead of doubling down when life gets hard?
Think about the last time you felt knocked off center — criticism, disappointment, fear, stress. Did you abandon your fundamentals or recommit to them? What would it look like to use challenges as triggers to increase your commitment to your protocol rather than decrease it?
3. What’s the gap between the person you’re capable of being and the person you’re actually being right now?
In this moment, reading this, what’s one area where you know you’re capable of better but you’re settling for less? What would closing that gap require? Not perfection — just movement toward your best self.
🔑 1 KEY TAKEAWAY
The worse you feel, the more committed you are to your protocol.
This single prescription from Phil Stutz changed Brian’s life — and it can change yours too. Most people have it backwards. When things are going well, they eat right, train hard, sleep enough, and show up for what matters. But when stress hits, when life gets chaotic, when they feel terrible — they abandon the very things that would help them most.
Anti-fragile confidence means building a protocol you can trust completely, then using adversity as the trigger to double down on it. Not because you feel motivated. Not because it’s easy. But because you’ve built such intense trust in yourself that you know: the version of you doing these things outperforms the version not doing them every single time.
This is the difference between fragile confidence (breaks under pressure), resilient confidence (bounces back after pressure), and anti-fragile confidence (gets stronger because of pressure). Your challenges aren’t obstacles to your protocol — they’re opportunities to prove to yourself that you can handle whatever comes.
As Brian reminds us: It’s supposed to be hard. Rule #1 of a heroic life is accepting that difficulty isn’t a bug in the system, it’s a feature. We want to lift heavy weights at the gym, not styrofoam. Yet in life, we avoid our “spiritual weights” — the hard conversations, the disciplined choices, the daily fundamentals that don’t feel exciting.
Your protocol is your collection of fundamentals. Your motivation will come and go. But your protocol — when you honor it especially when you don’t feel like it — becomes the foundation of unshakeable confidence. Not confidence that life will be easy, but confidence that you can handle what comes. That’s anti-fragile.
Chasing Excellence is an audience-supported project. To go deeper & to help us do even more, consider:
Subscribing to get our free posts or upgrading to receive the Daily Chase posts & the ChaseTracker app.
Grabbing one of our books: Chasing Excellence, Unlocking Potential, or The ABCs of Being Happy & Healthy.
Supporting one of our fantastic show sponsors.