Training vs Exercising: Why the 5-3-1 Method Destroys Random Workouts
The Full Episode Guide
🎧 In This Episode
We dive deep into the critical distinction between training and exercising amidst America's fitness boom.
While record numbers of Americans are moving their bodies, we explore why well-rounded training — not just exercise — is the key to true fitness and longevity.
Listen Now
Sponsored By
LMNT - Zero-sugar electrolyte drink
BetterHelp - Online therapy platform
Monarch Money - Personal finance hub
Function Health - Health data platform
OneSkin - Multifunctional SPF skincare
Quick Preview
Movement vs. Exercise vs. Training: Understanding the hierarchy from sedentary to athletic forever
The Sick-Well-Fit Continuum: Why fitness is your hedge against life's challenges
The 5-3-1 System: Our complete framework for well-rounded training in minimal time
Three Spheres Assessment: How to identify your weakest link and prioritize your training focus
❤️🔥 A Deeper Dive
Big Ideas
America's Fitness Paradox
We're experiencing record-high exercise participation — up 20% in recent years — yet there's a quality problem hiding in the numbers. While more people are moving (which is fantastic), many are gravitating toward "gentler" activities like Pilates and yoga rather than the more challenging strength and conditioning work that builds true fitness capacity.
The Training Hierarchy
We've identified a clear progression: Sedentary → Movement → Exercise → Training → Well-Rounded Training. Each level is better than the last, but most people stop at exercise when they could achieve so much more with intentional training.
The Sick-Well-Fit Continuum
CrossFit’s elegant framework shows that all the biomarkers your doctor measures (resting heart rate, blood pressure, body fat, fasting glucose) can be mapped on a continuum. Being "well" means you're in the normal ranges. Being "fit" means you're above normal—and that extra capacity serves as a hedge against sickness, injury, and the challenges life throws at you.
Key Distinctions
Exercise vs. Training
Exercise: Random movement for movement's sake, going to classes, following whatever workout feels good
Training: Purposeful development with measurement and progression toward specific outcomes
Constant Variation vs. Structure
Constant Variation: The CrossFit model of constantly changing workouts
Structure: An approach with consistent weekly patterns that allow for progressive overload
Reflection Questions
Honest Assessment: When someone invites you to try something physical (rock climbing, 5K run, yoga class, powerlifting), which activities make you immediately think "no way"? That's likely your weakest sphere.
Goal Clarity: Are you currently exercising or training? What specific, measurable outcomes are you working toward, and how would you know if you're making progress?
Time Investment: You're already carving out time for fitness — are you getting the maximum return on that investment, or could you achieve better results with more intentional programming?
Long-term Thinking: How will your current fitness approach serve you in 10, 20, or 30 years? Are you building capacity that transfers to real-life challenges?
Balance Check: Looking at strength, conditioning, and mobility, which sphere needs the most attention in your current routine?
Practice Opportunities
The Sit-to-Stand Test
From standing, lower yourself to a seated position on the ground and return to standing. Every time you use a hand, knee, or elbow for support, or lose your balance, subtract a point from 10. This simple test reveals your mobility, motor control, and stability capacity.
Sphere Self-Assessment
Rate yourself honestly in each area:
Strength: Can you squat, deadlift, or bench press your bodyweight? 1.5x? 2x?
Conditioning: What's your mile time? Can you sustain conversation during a 30-minute walk/jog?
Mobility: Can you perform the sit-to-stand test? Touch your toes? Reach overhead without arching your back?
Weekly Structure Audit
Map your current weekly routine against our 5-3-1 framework. Are you getting strength work three days per week? Are you going long once per week? Are you working different energy systems, or just doing the same type of workout repeatedly?
Key Takeaways
Movement is Better Than Nothing: We celebrate the fitness boom — any activity beats being sedentary, and we don't want to push people out of the boat by being too demanding.
Structure Beats Randomness: While variety has its place, consistent weekly patterns with progressive overload deliver better results than constantly changing workouts.
Balance Creates Resilience: The area under the curve — your total capacity across all domains — determines your fitness level and your ability to handle whatever life throws at you.
Small Investment, Big Returns: True fitness doesn't require hours in the gym daily. With smart programming, 2.5 hours per week can build remarkable capacity.
Assess and Adjust: Your weakest link determines your overall fitness. The biggest gains come from addressing your most limited area, not from getting even better at what you're already good at.
Training Transfers: We're not trying to get better at gym exercises for their own sake—we're building capacity that transfers to hiking mountains, carrying groceries, traveling independently, and maintaining quality of life as we age.
Chasing Excellence is an audience-supported project. To go deeper & to help us do even more, consider:
Subscribing to get our free posts or upgrading to receive the Daily Chase posts & bonus content.
Grabbing one of our books: Chasing Excellence, Unlocking Potential, or The ABCs of Being Happy & Healthy.
Supporting one of our fantastic show sponsors.